Friday, February 13, 2009

Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Filibuster?

Mr. Obama and the Congressional leadership have focused too much on the threat of Republican filibusters, in managing their massive bailout bills. Not too long ago, bills were passed with a majority vote, and filibusters were rare, and to be avoided. Now, the Republican minority threatens to use the filibuster to block any legislation, and the Democrats believe that they need 60 votes to get anything done. Nonsense!

The people voted for change, and it will not do anyone any good to fear filibusters. Especially when massive change and massive government intervention is needed, the Democratic approach should be to dare the Republicans to filibuster. Would the Republican Party long survive if the public saw them spending weeks holding up needed legislation? Would their pretense at fiscal responsibility long survive review, when they threw massive billions at the military with little oversight and much waste, when they passed massive tax cuts doubling the national debt, and when they conducted two wars without paying for them out of current income?

The Republicans have become the party of "cut tax and spent wildly." No filibuster by this bunch would last long. The Obama administration should welcome their filibusters, because they soon would collapse. Then, we could return to majority rule, instead of Republican bluster.

Monday, February 2, 2009

A Loophole on Prisons

The President's order to close Guantanamo and the secret CIA prisons is a good thing, even if one year is too long. However, he was silent on our prisons in Iraq, Afghanistan, and elsewhere. We need to close our foreign prisons, while providing due process for those long kept there. Thousands of prisoners need a way toward freedom, or an open process toward incarceration. Indefinite detention is Un-American.

A Loophole on Torture

The President's directive to follow the Army Manual on interrogations is a fine order, but it has a loophole for the CIA to review the issue, and to come back with recommendations for alternative methods. Why give the CIA this loophole, which could allow them to violate the international conventions against torture, again? What is the logic justifying this approach? The President needs to block this CIA activity.

First Cloud - Supplement

Richard Cohen and Ruth Marcus, in the Washington Post, and the Republican leadership, all have argued against prosecuting those who were involved in torture. The following was sent to the Post after Cohen's recent op ed:

Richard Cohen joins those who would forget the lawlessness of the Bush administration. He argues that intelligence agents who put forth a "sincere" effort should not have to fear a Congressional committee or a grand jury. He wants the finest people in these jobs, implying that a willingness to torture is part of the job description. What an interesting legal standard!

Let's be clear. Torture is illegal, and has been for many decades. It is a crime against humanity under international law, which is legally binding on the U.S. No one, under any circumstances, should be tortured. Any one who authorizes, participates in, or directly applies torture is a criminal. Our collective outrage over 9/11 is no excuse for torture. Without a clear and consistent rule of law, we lose our legal and moral standing in the world. That our CIA or military may have acted with the good intention of protecting our country is not an excuse.

We have learned too often that good people will do horrible things if asked to, under the right circumstances. If an individual cannot find the strength to refuse to torture, then the fear of punishment must deter. Imagine the sincere torturer, and shudder: we have to be better than that. Investigate, prosecute, and sentence the torturers, for our own sake.

Monday, January 12, 2009

First cloud on the horizon

The original intent was to wait until after the Inauguration, but the first cloud on the horizon has appeared: the apparent intent not to pursue investigations of violations of the law by the Bush administration.

This is not an issue of revenge, but something much more important: the principle that no one is above the law. Those who tortured, who violated citizen's rights, and who abandoned due process, need to be investigated and prosecuted. Those who come need to know that punishment is certain, to encourage them to stay within the limits of decency, rather than to push the boundary until it breaks.